Language · Media · TV

The Earth is round — needless to say?

While it is strange (and disturbing) that some religious conservatives dispute the scientific consensus on the age of the Earth and the universe, another article this past week (3-10-2018) — Yep, the Earth Is Still Round, Neil deGrasse Tyson Says — reminded me that there’s an even stranger group, namely, those who still play with the notion that the Earth is flat  (hopefully not just as performance art or for publicity).

The fact that an astrophysicist like Tyson found it necessary to address the notion of a flat Earth is telling. In the 21st century no less. But his answer provides a useful historical context and overview of scientific reasoning.

“Cosmos” host and astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson recently shot down the ideas of anyone who still thinks the Earth is flat. In a new YouTube video on the scientist’s StarTalk channel, he used examples ranging from space observations to ancient Greek experiments in a conversation with stand-up comedian Chuck Nice.

“What’s odd,” Tyson continued, “is there are people who think that Earth is flat but recognize that the moon is round. Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune and the sun are all spheres. But Earth is flat … something doesn’t square here.”

  • The science argument
  • The geometry argument

Is that the end of the story? No more flat-earthers?1

So, what if people still believe the Earth is flat?

“That’s OK,” Tyson quipped, “as long as you don’t run NASA.”


[1] Another article: “8 Times Flat-Earthers Tried to Challenge Science (and Failed) in 2017.”

One thought on “The Earth is round — needless to say?

  1. By contrast, this March 19, 2018, article “Nicolaus Copernicus Biography: Facts & Discoveries” hearkens back to the time when the Earth was believed to be the center of the universe.

    Although Copernicus’ model changed the layout of the universe, it still had its faults. For one thing, Copernicus held to the classical idea that the planets traveled in perfect circles. It wasn’t until the 1600s that Johannes Kepler proposed the orbits were instead ellipses. As such, Copernicus’ model featured the same epicycles that marred in Ptolemy’s work, although there were fewer.

    According to Rudnick, Copernicus went beyond simply creating a model of the solar system.

    “All his work involved a new cosmological principle originated by him. It is today called the Genuine Copernican Cosmological Principle and says, ‘The Universe as observed from any planet looks much the same,'” Rudnick wrote.

Comments are closed.